In the wake of the verdict of Sean Bell’s murder trial, I am at an honest loss for words. It is a good thing because more words will only add to the glut of opinions since this horrific loss of life. Kevin Powell wrote about his feelings, his interactions with the Bell family, his dismay at the dearth of political action. His thesis, as I took it, was that police brutality stands as par for the course in terms of this nation’s treatment of Blacks.
I wrote about this after the outrage specifically because this story, like many others, should not die at the end of the capricious news cycle. Rawkus’s founders, good men that they are, would prefer I crank out some knee-jerk reply to a Black man’s death splayed in the headlines. I don’t really think anyone could understand, or empathize with, the feeling of the hunted. Now, the Victim Argument has been rehashed and signified so frequently that it diminishes the meaning of our specific plight. Our plight is not that Sean Bell or Amadou Diallo has died. It is not a tragedy that Michael Vick is in jail or that Wesley Snipes is there too. It is not an injustice that Remy Ma will face time or that T.I. will not. The most disheartening part of this verdict, of the headline voodoo that’s been imparted so casually and so maliciously, is that we have no agency. We are participants in a predetermined machination of death and destruction. To write about it hip-hop, as much as I love the music and its influence, is to witness this ongoing destruction firsthand. Thankfully, a few media outlets exist solely to bring light to new music but the more “impressive” statistical websites barter in images of nude black women, confused flashy rappers, and rumor-mongering. Sean Bell is a part of this shameful song and dance too. The Reverend Al Sharpton and the esteemed hip-hop activist end up playing similar roles in this narrative: the folks who endlessly stir the muck, have their cries ignored, yet increase their public profiles even as the issue itself fades. Sadly, this is not on their shoulders. Sharpton would have observers believe that his political rhetoric extends past the stump or his news show cameos. Powell, too, wields his power only in a limited sphere of maturing hip-hop fans who have secured professional prestige and some social leverage. I can only ask more questions about where it all leads. If we are intent on endorsing negative images of ourselves, how can we blame the larger society for agreeing with the power of those images?
I am not having a conservative catharsis however. No Jason Whitlock or Larry Elder exists in my brain. The principles of imperialism, colonialism, apartheid and other efficient systems of long-term oppression insure that there will be no sudden breaks of the mental shackles that hold us in perpetual check. Blacks did not create those systems, even if African traders were complicit in the slave commerce originating in the Western part of the continent. In the same vein, Blacks did not create nor do they control the media interests of today. Just as the Bible (original media sensation) pegged us as the cursed people in the King James version to establish political hegemony, CNN, Fox News, HBO, and ClearChannel have spread a similar image of cursed, exotic people. So, even if we “buy into it,” as a lot of Cosbys complain, it would not be on the shelf without some self-interested corporate, and sovereign entities putting the price sticker on it, with the alluring packaging and sale coupons. Sean Bell, and the merits of the prosecution’s case against the three police officers who shot him, cannot be overlooked as pieces of this industrial mind-bending. Although Bell’s story of a strip club bachelor party read as unsavory to much of the middling public, it may not have struck the same chord if it had been a bunch of young Italian men, or young Jewish men or young WASP men celebrating pre-nuptials at Scores. Those men would not have had a run-in with the police because they would not be suspected of doing more than getting soused at the topless joint. They would also have been less prone to the police paranoia that plagues Black men in similarly innocuous settings.

We have all the facts, seemingly. The newspapers provide every form of spin and every accompanying version ranging from “he should have never threatened the police” to “killer cops with beer on their breath.” It is enough to make a grown man wring his hands in frustration. Sean Bell will not decide on his legacy much the same as many Black men await some earthly authority to judge us after we’ve gone. Rather than add to the growing chorus with a plan of attack, or composed boycotting, I’ll just list the things I do not want to see Generation Hip-Hop do to commemorate such an egregious act.
1. Make a protest song to support the protest song - This means you Papoose, NYOIL, Immortal Technique, Saigon and the other political rappers who keep themselves relevant through tragedy, grief, bickering, cynicism and a sense of world doom. This is not to say there isn’t a place for these voices or sentiments. I have listened to these artists mount valid protest to the inane, baseless affinities hip-hop has to both drugs and violence. In this case though, the negativity has already flooded our brains. A song about lynching the police or the effects of the police state sounds like more static in this complex struggle.
2. Stage a boycott through consumerism - I do not want to see any T-Shirts bearing Sean Bell’s name and a police chalk outline. I do not promote emblems of death and injustice on my body. I will not tuck away some shirt in my drawer as a testament to how I feel.

Unnecessary Reminders from The Obvious Department of Death
3. Appear on a news talk show - Chuck Creekmur this means you. Nas, Chuck D and KRS-1 ought to stay out of it as well. Mos Def…chill. Becoming one of the shouting talking heads further renders this man’s life and death meaningless. Becoming a talking point amidst seven or eight commercial breaks does the same. Police brutality will never be a national news story as long as police are largely responsible for the “well-being” of poor communities. To Sean Hannity, to Anderson Cooper, to Larry King these are issues of small consequence until the ratings game calls.

“Ah…let me finish sir.”
4. Rally, protest or march - The post-Civil Rights era march is an operation in futility. The marching no longer yields a serious reply from those who stand by, but great bewilderment. The Rockefeller Drug Laws, cause celebre of the Def Jam crew, were challenged with a march in Midtown New York. That went especially poorly. Russell Simmons and LL Cool J could not inspire legislative change for mandatory minimums among crack-cocaine offenders. The well-intentioned protests slither down unwelcome streets, jam traffic and draw attention from tourists. They also position capitalist, hording men like Russell Simmons as champions of social justice when these roles seem at odds. This is not time for figureheads, for useless demagoguery.